Sat 24 Sep 2005

Theocratic Dominion Pakistan

posted by: کردار, filed under: زندگی

My boss has stopped me from reporting on minorities’ rights, when I told him that I was going to voice opinion of minorities leaders on two much talked-about and little-published cases in the country –one alleged abduction of Hindu girl in Sindh and second public riots against Christians in Punjab. But my boss says reporting on these issues would incite violence –probably fanning Hindu Muslim hatred –and might draw strong reaction from so called “Islamists”. I know he is a professional journalist and understands that I was tempted to report on this issue by very basic principle of journalism: balanced coverage of each event. But he is responsible to safeguard interests of our media organization and this responsibility invokes “self-censorship”. It does come into action when there is an issue linked to religion because prosecuting someone on blasphemy laws is easiest thing to do in Islamic Republic of Pakistan. And as I write these lines, private run Aaj Television is airing live a debate on alleged kidnapping of Hindu girl Sapna from her home in interior Sindh. Sapna has already made a televised statement saying she left her home to marry the man of her own choice and embraced Islam. But Hindu leaders says she was forced into making such statement and converting to Islam “as any girl after being kidnapped and held for so many days can be broken to make any remarks.” The Aaj TV debate has drawn same reaction as my boss had predicted. There are many people making calls to live programme and registering their annoyance on airing the issue. Most of them believed that Sapna case had more to do with love and little to minorities’ rights. Although, there were some other callers, mainly Hindu, who said kidnapping of Hindu girls in Sindh province continues on wide scale, the host of programme seemed attempting to suggest that alleged Sapna kidnapping was an issue of law & order as Muslim women face almost same situation. Well…say he is right to some extend can we deny that Islam has vigorously emphasized on protection of minority right? Then why voicing minorities opinion is a taboo? And when you air or report something like that you fear a backfire? There were some reports that a Hindu family was manhandled and arrested in of NWFP villages after Holy Quran was recovered from a field near their house and they were allege for desecration of the holy book. Have you got any evidence that it was their act? Develop personal grudge against someone and charge him/her with blasphemy –easiest way to serve your vested interests when opponent is a non-Muslim. And rest assure nobody would dare to favour “the blasphemer,” even if someone does he would risk his life Disclaimer: Writer is a practicing Muslim and holds Pakistani Nationality

7 Comments »

Right Click Here for TrackBack URI

  1. Comment by Nabeel, Saturday, September 24, 2005 @ 9:40 pm

    فسانہ زندگی، آپ اردو کیا لکھنا بھول گئے۔ کبھی کبھی نمودار ہوتے ہیں اور وہ بھی انگریزی میں۔ خیر پوچھنا تھا کہ کیا آپ نے محفل فورم دیکھی ہے۔ تشریف لائیے پسند آئے گی۔

  2. Comment by Nabeel, Saturday, September 24, 2005 @ 9:41 pm

    By the way, I am also planning to write on similar topic..

  3. Comment by Kirdar, Sunday, September 25, 2005 @ 4:18 pm

    Nabeel! thanks for invitation…I have visited Urdu forum once…but nowadays I m away from my home computer..that’s way you see my post written in English

  4. Comment by شعیب صفدر, Sunday, November 6, 2005 @ 2:12 pm

    عید مبارک

  5. Comment by منیراحمدطاہر, Monday, November 7, 2005 @ 8:22 am

    EID MUBARAK

  6. Comment by Amir, Sunday, November 20, 2005 @ 12:29 am

    Its a sensitive issue and needs a serious dialogue. I never bothered to think about the rights of minorities or their issues before I met some of them outside Pakistan. I realized that they are quite bitter about how they are treated in Pakistan. Some of them discuss the discriminating attitude of Pakistanis towards them openly infront of foreigners which was quite embarrasing for me. Initially I thought they are biased but gradually I realized that there is strong injustice prevalant in Pakistani society against minorities. I will just write about one interesting observation, on Eid day we were standing outside the mosque. Sorry I forgot to tell you that I am currently in Austria. One of our friends said what do think these Austrians would be thinking about us since there are about 20 of us standing here and some of us are wearing Shalwar Kameez. The other friend said, Austrians must must be saying “Choroian Di Eid Hay” (its the Eid of sweapers). We all laughed yet it showed the kind of remarks we pass on the minorities on their festivals.

    In my opinion you should write on the issue, however, you may use a light tone and ‘Hola Hath’.

    Regards,

    Amir

  7. Comment by earf, Wednesday, May 2, 2007 @ 8:28 pm

    this is comment

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>